–Martin Luther King Jr.
“What are you getting so worked up about? You don’t live in California and you probably never will. This has nothing to do with you.”
Her words began to mix with those of the much too peppy news reporter, swirling together, making me sick to my stomach. I no longer remember her exact words but I remember how my body felt as the reporter read the results of the California elections, as she sealed the fate of my community in a few simple words. Proposition 8, the Proposition that would take away the right of all gay and lesbian couples in California to marry, had passed. The people of California, in a 52 to 48% vote, had effectively looked every gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender person in the eyes and said “you are less than your neighbors, your rights are not your rights anymore”.
My mother and I had argued about this before. My mother is in no way homophobic- she loves me as much now as she did before I came out and truly believes that there is nothing wrong with being gay. She is, however, far from a social activist and my intensity and propensity for social justice issues is just a bit much for her. Naturally, the decision of Californians to take away the rights of people just like me brought up different reactions from the two of us. Being a firm believer of the King Jr. school of thought that “injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere”, I took the decision personally. I was scared. I cried. My stomach had that never-ending pit feeling to it and I felt like I had been attacked, like I was seen as a bad person, as less than, because I happened to love other women. My heart, that organ we all take for granted so often, felt as though someone had opened my chest and squeezed it tightly in a vice.
My mother, however, a firm believer of my grandparents school of thought that everyone should take care of themselves and that if it didn’t affect you directly it wasn’t of concern to you, had quite a different reaction. She had no reaction at all. The only reason she even crossed the line and said what she said was because I had done exactly what she would soon do to me. I pushed her to the edge. My sarcastic whispers throughout her news programs and heartfelt tirades about the injustice of it all had become too much for her and forced her to react. So like a dog whose ears had been pulled just one too many times by her own offspring, my mother bit back. And her comment, as it was intended to do, shut me up. It wasn’t that I didn’t know what to say that kept me silent, it was that I hadn’t considered that someone I had grown up with, someone I had learned so much from, would think so differently from me. I didn’t understand because I was so angry, so hurt that I couldn’t think clearly enough to bring her in, to help her understand why I was so moved to fight against this.
The way my mother had grown up and been raised was so far detached from what I was experiencing that I don’t know if she could have felt what I was feeling even if she tried her hardest. Her life, or at least her experience of it, simply did not include an understanding of what it feels like to be a lesbian or gay youth in my lifetime. And there I was trying to explain to her something that may as well have been said in Russian. I was explaining photography to the man who had never seen the light of day. It wasn’t by any means her fault that we didn’t have a common language to talk about this issue, but it frustrated me just the same.
I wanted nothing more than share with her what I was feeling because I knew it would change her mind, but the way I was going about it was wrong. Instead of trying to make her understand something that she couldn’t, like being a young lesbian in such an unsure time, I had to translate to a language that made sense in her life. And I realized that if I wanted her to relate to me, if I wanted anyone to relate to me and understand why this fight and so many like it were so vital, I had to relate my experiences to those of the people I was trying to convince. I had to help them realize what I knew to be true, that all of us are part of this world, that we all make up a “network of mutuality” where what affects one person has the potential to affect all other. In this way of thinking it is necessary for us all to be responsible for and with the rights and needs of others in our community, our state, our country, our network. If one group of people is being oppressed, if one child is growing up in fear because being who he or she is would put them at risk then the entire community is being oppressed and living in fear. And if they aren’t at that moment, then they could be at any other. When injustice exists in our world in any form it has the potential to exist in our world in any other. The injustice facing GLBT people today could very well be the injustice facing any other group tomorrow.
My argument with my mother, though it ended in a blowout of epic proportions between the two of us, has helped both of us to see our world differently. My mother is beginning to understand that I fight because I know in my heart I have to and that I have a responsibility to do so, but she has also begun to see things as more interconnected. When she hears of young children committing suicide because they had been bullied and tormented for being thought to be gay, she calls me to say that something needs to be done. It’s no longer “it isn’t happening here, what do you care?” No, now it’s “this is happening and it needs to stop.” Like Harvey Milk argued during the fight for gay rights in the 1970’s, you’ve got to come out to everyone you know because it’s a lot harder to discriminate against someone you know. Though he was referring to sexuality when he said it, Harvey’s comments ring true for all walks of life. You have to “come out”, you have to be open and honest and talk with people about who you are and what you believe because if you don’t, you and your ideas become invisible and invisible ideas don’t spark change. In my argument with my mother I had become so blinded by my own outrage and pain that I didn’t think to let her in. In that moment I didn’t think of her as a part of my world community because I couldn’t make her understand, but what I needed to remember was that everyone is part of this community, even when they disagree, and it is not only our responsibility to fight for those being oppressed, but it is our duty to find ways to communicate and open discourse with those who, whether intentionally or not, perpetuate the existence of oppression.
The fight for justice is far from over, not just because of this one example of inequality in the GLBT community, but because while injustice exists anywhere we have to continue to fight for justice everywhere. My argument with my mother served as a reminder that when we try to exist outside of the “network of mutuality” we end up pushing away those who are our allies, who fight alongside us and for us. We have to continue to fight, there is no denying that, but we must do so in a way that invites people into the struggle or we run the risk of forcing them against us.


